em driver testing
quetzal at zone3000.net
Wed Nov 8 16:55:18 UTC 2006
On Wednesday, 8 November 2006 at 9:26:26 -0700, Scott Long wrote:
> Jeremy Chadwick wrote:
> >On Wed, Nov 08, 2006 at 04:40:03PM +0200, Nikolay Pavlov wrote:
> >>Well i have 5.5 box with very similar symptomatic :)
> >>I do not see watchdog timeouts on it, but a lot of UP/DOWN events.
> >Are you sure this is the same problem as what's being discussed
> >here? If you revert to a previous kernel or em driver, does the
> >problem (link up/down) go away? Are you sure you don't actually
> >have a flaky cable or RJ45 connector? What does the switch your
> >NIC is connected to say? (does it show link going up and down)
> >I feel horrible for both Scott and Jack -- I think there's tons
> >of people coming out of the woodwork with "ME TOO" comments who
> >may in fact be suffering from other problems, and are looking for
> >a scapegoat thread.
> The timeout/watchdog mechanism in the interface layer has been a problem
> ever since the MPSAFE work was done on the network stack. It's prone to
> races, and as the OS has improved and gotten faster over the past 2
> years, those races have gotten bigger. In a way, it's a actually a
> positive indication of progress and improvement =-)
> I don't doubt that there are users with other problems. We spent some
> time collecting as much user data as we could in order to find patterns
> and weed out the uncommon cases. But this timer/watchdog thing looks to
> be a strong candidate for being the root cause of many of the problems.
> We'll continue to investigate these problems and address other drivers.
Thanks Scott. From my side, I'd like to say that I'm always ready to
help you in testing.
- Best regards, Nikolay Pavlov. <<<-----------------------------------
More information about the freebsd-stable