Grandfather dependencies completely out of control
Alexander at Leidinger.net
Mon May 3 12:11:20 UTC 2010
Quoting Doug Barton <dougb at FreeBSD.org> (from Sun, 02 May 2010
> On 05/02/10 15:28, Joe Marcus Clarke wrote:
>> On 5/2/10 5:19 PM, Doug Barton wrote:
>>> On 05/02/10 03:21, Koop Mast wrote:
>>>> One of the scripts provided by devel/glib20 is a perl script.
>>>> That is the reason why
>>>> we need perl.
>>> Thanks for the response, couple things come to mind. First, how many
>>> things actually make use of those perl/python scripts? If the number is
>>> small they should probably be OPTIONS that default to off, or slave
>>> ports as Thomas suggested.
>> The script (glib-mkenums) is actually very important to almost all ports
>> which depend on glib. Yes, what Thomas suggested could be done with
>> some considerable work. What might be better is to have someone versed
>> in shell scripting translate this script to sh. I think the GNOME guys
>> would be fine to accept that.
> Please note that I'm not overwhelmingly interested in this particular
> case. I'm more concerned about the general problem of grandfather
in make.conf. This will get rid of the grandparent-deps.
The problem with this is, that a lot of ports hardcode
grandparent-libs. This is not a FreeBSD problem, this is a libtool (at
least 1.x) problem and a pkg-config problem (adding grandparent-libs
even if they are not necessary). So with this switch, you can not
lookup potential candidates for an upgrade, by looking at the
Because of the libtool/pkg-config problem all childs of a
"problematic" lib will contain a reference to the lib, even if the
particular lib is just a dependency of a lib which the current port
uses. To make this description more explicit: if your port uses
libGRAPH (I made upt this name) and libGRAPH is linked to libjpeg and
libpng via libtool (at least 1.x), but your port is not directly using
symbols from libjpeg or libpng, the binaries of your port will have
libpng *and* libjpeg hardcoded.
See /usr/ports/Tools/scripts/explicit_lib_depends.sh for a script
which tells you which libs are hardcoded in the files (if they are in
bin/ or lib/) of your (installed) port. Feel free to improve the
script, I didn't touch it since 3 years because the software in the
ports tree was not in a state where it made sense to finish the "NOT
YET" part or extend the scope of files to analyze.
A baby is an alimentary canal with a loud voice
at one end and no responsibility at the other.
http://www.Leidinger.net Alexander @ Leidinger.net: PGP ID = B0063FE7
http://www.FreeBSD.org netchild @ FreeBSD.org : PGP ID = 72077137
More information about the freebsd-ports