ports/159087: perl package conflicts with JSON::PP and other modules

[Peter Vereshagin]

>Number:         159087
>Category:       ports
>Synopsis:       perl package conflicts with JSON::PP and other modules
>Confidential:   no
>Severity:       non-critical
>Priority:       low
>Responsible:    freebsd-ports-bugs
>State:          open
>Quarter:        
>Keywords:       
>Date-Required:
>Class:          change-request
>Submitter-Id:   current-users
>Arrival-Date:   Thu Jul 21 14:20:09 UTC 2011
>Closed-Date:
>Last-Modified:
>Originator:     Peter Vereshagin
>Release:        releng_7 as of May, 2011
>Organization:
Private
>Environment:
FreeBSD teh.ost 7.4-STABLE FreeBSD 7.4-STABLE #10: Mon May  2 16:12:55 MSD 2011     peter at vereshagin.org:/CONF  i386

>Description:
I recently upgraded to the lang/perl-5.14 from lang/perl-5.12.
The lang/perl-5.12 in it turn was upgraded from lang/perl-5.8.
I notice that more modules formerly installed from separate ports are included
in that port. This led me to the duplicates of the ports and I deleted them by
mean of my Inclusure utility: 
    http://gitweb.vereshagin.org/inclusure
    https://github.com/petr999/inclusure
Such a ports in question make more disk space used and may lead to the strange
things to happen on the system, at least their files may conflict in the 'man'
and 'bin' directories as shown here with 'converters/p5-JSON-PP' port.
I'm pretty sure  there should be the CONFLICTS added to teh eveery
'lang/perl5.X' port to avoid confusion.
>How-To-Repeat:
    # portinstall lang/perl5.12 
    # portinstall converters/p5-JSON-PP
    [..]
    Installing /usr/local/man/man1/json_pp.1
    [..]
    Installing /usr/local/bin/json_pp
    # pkg_delete -fx perl-5 && cd /usr/ports/lang/perl5.14 && make install &&\
    > perl-after-upgrade -f
    # pkg_delete -x p5-JSON-PP
    pkg_delete: '/usr/local/man/man1/json_pp.1.gz' fails original MD5 checksum -
    not deleted.
    pkg_delete: '/usr/local/bin/json_pp' fails original MD5 checksum - not
    deleted.
    pkg_delete: couldn't entirely delete package (perhaps the packing list is
    incorrectly specified?)
>Fix:
Put CONFLICTS into the lang/perl5.14/Makefile on those packages:
    $ pkg_info -L perl-5.14.1 | perl -Mstrict -Mautodie -wE 'open my $fh, "<", "/usr/ports/INDEX-7"; my %ports; while(my $line = <$fh>) { chomp $line; $line =~ s/^([^|]+)-[\d\.,_]+\|.*$/$1/g; $ports{ $line } = 1; } close $fh; while(<>) { if( m%/usr/local/lib/perl5/5.14.1/(mach/)?(.+)\.pm$% ) { my $mod = "p5-".($2 =~ s%/%-%gr); if( defined $ports{ $mod } ) { say $mod; } } }'

Patch is supplied.

Patch attached with submission follows:

diff -u -r lang/perl5.14.orig/Makefile lang/perl5.14/Makefile
--- lang/perl5.14.orig/Makefile	2011-06-19 14:27:11.000000000 +0400
+++ lang/perl5.14/Makefile	2011-06-27 12:53:22.000000000 +0400
@@ -25,7 +25,54 @@
 
 CONFLICTS=	perl-5.6.* perl-5.8.* perl-threaded-5.8.* \
 		perl-5.10.* perl-threaded-5.10.* \
-		perl-5.12.* perl-threaded-5.12.*
+		perl-5.12.* perl-threaded-5.12.* \
+		p5-Archive-Extract-[0-9]* p5-Archive-Tar-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Attribute-Handlers-[0-9]* p5-AutoLoader-[0-9]* \
+		p5-CPAN-Meta-[0-9]* p5-CPAN-Meta-YAML-[0-9]* \
+		p5-CPANPLUS-[0-9]* p5-CPANPLUS-Dist-Build-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Digest-[0-9]* p5-ExtUtils-CBuilder-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-Command-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-Constant-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-Install-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-MakeMaker-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-Manifest-[0-9]* \
+		p5-ExtUtils-ParseXS-[0-9]* p5-File-Fetch-[0-9]* \
+		p5-File-Path-[0-9]* p5-File-Temp-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Filter-Simple-[0-9]* p5-Getopt-Long-[0-9]* \
+		p5-HTTP-Tiny-[0-9]* p5-I18N-LangTags-[0-9]* \
+		p5-IO-Zlib-[0-9]* p5-IPC-Cmd-[0-9]* p5-JSON-PP-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Locale-Codes-[0-9]* p5-Locale-Maketext-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Locale-Maketext-Simple-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Log-Message-[0-9]* p5-Log-Message-Simple-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Math-BigInt-[0-9]* p5-Math-BigRat-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Math-Complex-[0-9]* p5-Memoize-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Module-Build-[0-9]* p5-Module-CoreList-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Module-Load-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Module-Load-Conditional-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Module-Loaded-[0-9]* p5-Module-Metadata-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Module-Pluggable-[0-9]* p5-NEXT-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Net-Ping-[0-9]* p5-Object-Accessor-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Package-Constants-[0-9]* p5-Params-Check-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Parse-CPAN-Meta-[0-9]* p5-Perl-OSType-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Pod-Escapes-[0-9]* p5-Pod-Parser-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Pod-Perldoc-[0-9]* p5-Pod-Simple-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Term-ANSIColor-[0-9]* p5-Term-UI-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Test-Harness-[0-9]* p5-Test-Simple-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Text-Balanced-[0-9]* p5-Text-ParseWords-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Thread-Queue-[0-9]* p5-Tie-File-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Tie-RefHash-[0-9]* p5-Time-Local-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Version-Requirements-[0-9]* p5-XSLoader-[0-9]* \
+		p5-autodie-[0-9]* p5-base-[0-9]* p5-bignum-[0-9]* \
+		p5-parent-[0-9]* p5-Compress-Raw-Bzip2-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Compress-Raw-Zlib-[0-9]* p5-Data-Dumper-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Devel-PPPort-[0-9]* p5-Digest-MD5-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Digest-SHA-[0-9]* p5-Encode-[0-9]* p5-Errno-[0-9]* \
+		p5-IO-[0-9]* p5-MIME-Base64-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Math-BigInt-FastCalc-[0-9]* p5-Storable-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Sys-Syslog-[0-9]* p5-Time-HiRes-[0-9]* \
+		p5-Time-Piece-[0-9]* p5-Unicode-Normalize-[0-9]* \
+		p5-threads-[0-9]* p5-threads-shared-[0-9]* \
+		p5-version-[0-9]* p5-CGI.pm-[0-9]*
 
 OPTIONS=	DEBUGGING	"Build with debugging support"		off \
 		GDBM		"Build GDBM_File extension"		off \
Only in lang/perl5.14: work


>Release-Note:
>Audit-Trail:
>Unformatted: