FreeBSD 4.9 / VRRP / vlan

[Mathieu Arnold]

+-le 28/11/2003 17:12 +0100, Pawel Malachowski écrivait :
| On Fri, Nov 28, 2003 at 04:44:30PM +0100, Mathieu Arnold wrote:
| 
|> ip address on the vlan subnet (say ping 62.233.44.132), and I tcpdump -i
|> vlan20, I see arp requests going out, on the tcpdump I launched on the
|> according host, I see the arp request coming in, the response going out,
|> but I don't see any response going in on the router. If I manually add
|> the mac address (arp -s ...) I see the icmp requests going, arriving on
|> the host, the echo reply going back, but they're not received on the
|> router. So, there is a problem somewhere (it's not a switch problem
|> because with a cable between the 2 fxp it's the exact same problem.)
| 
| Heh, this is exactly the same procedure I tried yesterday at night.
| Not with freevrrpd-ed IP 192.168.1.1/24 (cause it works), but with
| non freevrrpded 10.255.255.1/24 (compare with my previously posted
| setup in this thread).
| I am not able to communicate using 10.255.255.{1,2}/24 after starting
| freevrrpd on at least one side, in the same manner as You describe above
| (cleared/static arp didn't help).
| 
| So, it looks like:
| 0. Something is wrong here,
| 1. It is possible to workaround this somehow, using one `trash'
|    subnet (as my 10.255.255.0/24) assigned to vlan interface
|    by hand, and second, `proper' subnet, assigned with freevrrpd.
| 
| Maybe please get some obsolete vlan and try to use my setup with
| no modifiactions, it partially works for me, it should elsewhere.

When bruno tried to do that (I've not tested yet, so I trust him on it)
freevrrp failed to add an alias to the fxp because there's already a route
to the other firewall for the network (which ospf added).
But I'm gonna try.

-- 
Mathieu Arnold