background fsck high load on 8.1

[Sergi Seira]

Hello,

thanks for the explanation, I can confirm this behaviour on serveral upgraded boxes.

We'll look forward to journaled soft updates or maybe switching to zfs.
Anyway it isn't happening that much, only on hard resets.

Regards,
Sergi



On 13/04/11 17:05, Kirk McKusick wrote:
>> Date: Tue, 12 Apr 2011 15:14:42 +0200
>> From: Sergi Seira<s.seira at cdmon.com>
>> To: freebsd-current at freebsd.org
>> Subject: background fsck high load on 8.1
>>
>> Hello,
>>
>> We've experienced that background fsck on 8.1 degrades server
>> performance on a higher degree than in previous fbsd versions (6.3,
>> 7.3; amd64).
>>
>> We've noticed it after upgrading - same hardware - to a 8.1-RELEASE.
>> Now, performance of other services (i.e. apache, mysql) during a
>> background fsck falls miserably.
>>
>> Is there any way to calm fsck down?, nice(1)?, some sysctl?
>>
>> We have also gmirror, but we prevent to rebuild it if there is a
>> fsck running in background.
>>
>> Thanks for your help,
>> regards,
>> Sergi
>
> This is the first report that I have heard of the higher level of
> slowdown by background fsck on 8.X systems. My guess is that it
> comes about from work done to make the I/O subsystem faster which
> in turn allows fsck to have a higher impact.
>
> For a period we were working on a kernel feature (associated with
> nice) that would allow the system to throttle I/O activity for a
> given process. It turns out to be a much harder problem than it at
> first appears. We set this aside when we got journaled soft updates
> working as they eliminate the need for background fsck. While
> journaled soft updates are too big of a change to be merged back
> into the 8.X tree, we do expect them to be used by default on 9.X
> systems.
>
> 	Kirk McKusick


-- 
---8<--------------------
   Sergi Seira i Espunya
  Departament de Sistemes
     s.seira at cdmon.com
       www.cdmon.com
        93 567 7577
        902 364 138
        91 182 2767
          ext:161
-------------------->8---