ATAng vs Aladdin chipset
Pete Carah
pete at ns.altadena.net
Sun Sep 14 03:03:27 PDT 2003
ASUS P5A or P5AB (one of each now) - won't boot without setting
hw.ata.ata_dma=0. GEOM recognizes the drive itself but then the reads
of the disklabels fail with a message that I can't find in the source,
about a DMA failure. System then prompts to mount root and nothing I
type works. I see looking at the list archive that I'm not the only
one with this problem. The message appears 3 times per drive with some
seconds between, implying to me that it is (at least) a missing interrupt
(or completely missing operation?).
If anyone wants I could take the trouble to set up a serial console
and capture the output. I suspect that is already done somewhere
though.
Approx same cvsup time works fine in my laptop running ICH3 chipset.
Then again, Intel != Acer :-)
At least I figured out a bypass easily... Makes "make world" lots
slower but at least works.
Other (unrelated?) minor problem in past (don't know if it's still there);
acpi timer doesn't work right on this chipset either (ran clock at approx
double rate with lots of "went backwards" messages). Appears better now at
least on one example (non-ASUS board, though) - at least ntp is happy.
-- Pete
More information about the freebsd-current
mailing list