Problem booting FreeBSD 13.0 and 13.1 on a box with an external HP enclose - panic in make_dev_alias_v

From: Rainer Duffner <rainer_at_ultra-secure.de>
Date: Mon, 12 Sep 2022 15:46:48 UTC
Hi,

I have created a PR for this, but it has not attracted any attention from anybody.

https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=266183


Basically, I have a HP DL 380 Gen 10 Server with the following hardware:

ses0: <HPE 12G SAS Exp Card 5.08>; ID: 51402ec010b61100
Desc     Dev     Model                     Ident                Size/Status
-        -       -                         -                    Not Installed
-        da0     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A19BFQXE1815     1T
-        da1     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1BTFQXE1815     1T
-        da2     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1GGFQXE1815     1T
-        da3     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1B6FQXE1815     1T
-        da4     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1AGFQXE1815     1T
-        da5     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1EQFQXE1815     1T
-        da6     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1H2FQXE1815     1T
-        da7     HP EG001200JWFVA          48D0A1FMFQXE1815     1T
-        da8     HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK1F14Y             1T
-        da9     HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK248J7             1T
-        da10    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK2MLXX             1T
-        da11    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK2FRNL             1T
-        da12    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK12X9N             1T
-        da13    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK2LREQ             1T
-        da14    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK2H5CH             1T
-        da15    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK2ER85             1T
-        da16    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JD0N             1T
-        da17    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JBDM             1T
-        da18    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JD8E             1T
-        da19    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3ES09             1T
-        da20    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JCPY             1T
-        da21    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JBDQ             1T
-        da22    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3JB3X             1T
-        da23    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK3ERTQ             1T
-        -       -                         -                    Not Installed
-        -       -                         -                    Not Installed
-        -       -                         -                    Not Installed
-        -       -                         -                    Not Installed

ses1: <HPE E208i-p SR Gen10 3.53>; ID: 51402ec011040770
Desc     Dev     Model                     Ident                Size/Status
Internal Device  -       -                         -                    OK

Temperatures: Controller Temperature Sensors  : 69 C, emc_1464_int:0:7:Vendor defined : 44 C, emc_1464_ext1:1:1:Chip ASIC     : 69 C, emc_1464_ext2:2:8:Vendor define : 58 C, emc_1464_ext3:3:6:Vendor define : 51 C

ses2: <HPE D3710 5.04>; ID: 5001438041aad880
Desc     Dev     Model                     Ident                Size/Status
{"Name":"Drive bay"} -       -                         -                    Not Installed
{"Name":"DriveBay1"} da24    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5DDT0             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay2"} da25    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5FY2N             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay3"} da26    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5JHPF             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay4"} da27    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5FV96             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay5"} da28    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5FV9P             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay6"} da29    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5FWHX             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay7"} da30    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5JH9R             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay8"} da31    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK5B2XA             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay9"} da32    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK72ZM9             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay10"}    da33    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK6RNDD             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay11"}    da34    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK72VXL             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay12"}    da35    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK6RMHA             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay13"}    da36    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK72ZLX             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay14"}    da37    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK6S3ST             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay15"}    da38    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK72ZH8             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay16"}    da39    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK72H6S             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay17"}    da40    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK7Y2H2             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay18"}    da41    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK826HG             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay19"}    da42    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK86CZM             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay20"}    da43    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK89JCS             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay21"}    da44    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK827M0             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay22"}    da45    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK89LYY             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay23"}    da46    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK7ZC2A             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay24"}    da47    HP EG001200JWJNQ          WFK7Y2HJ             1T
{"Name":"DriveBay25"}    -       -                         -                    Not Installed

Temperatures: {"Name":"Temperature sensor"}   : 46 C, {"Name":"LocalIoModule-Sensor[0]"}  : 29 C, {"Name":"LocalIoModule-Sensor[1]"}  : 29 C, {"Name":"LocalExpander-CpuSensor[0]"}   : 46 C, {"Name":"PartnerIoModule-Sensor[0]"}: 29 C, {"Name":"PartnerIoModule-Sensor[1]"}: 30 C, {"Name":"PartnerExpander-CpuSensor[0]"} : 46 C, {"Name":"PowerSupply[1]-InletSensor[0]"}: 31 C, {"Name":"PowerSupply[1]-Sensor[0]"} : 36 C, {"Name":"PowerSupply[2]-InletSensor[0]"}: 29 C, {"Name":"PowerSupply[2]-Sensor[0]"} : 33 C, {"Name":"Backplane-Sensor[0]"}  : 26 C, {"Name":"Backplane-Sensor[1]"}  : 26 C, {"Name":"Backplane-Sensor[2]"}  : 27 C, {"Name":"Backplane-Sensor[3]"}  : 26 C, {"Name":"Backplane-Sensor[4]"}  : 25 C

ses3: <HPE P408e-p SR Gen10 3.53>; ID: 51402ec01361cce0
Desc     Dev     Model                     Ident                Size/Status
Internal Device  -       -                         -                    OK

Temperatures: Controller Temperature Sensors  : 68 C, emc_1464_int:0:7:Vendor defined : 52 C, emc_1464_ext1:1:1:Chip ASIC     : 68 C, emc_1464_ext2:2:8:Vendor define : 53 C, emc_1464_ext3:3:6:Vendor define : 58 C

ses4: <HPE P408i-a SR Gen10 3.53>; ID: 51402ec010284310
Desc     Dev     Model                     Ident                Size/Status
Internal Device  -       -                         -                    OK
ArrayElement0000 da48    HP EG000300JWFVB          48B0A025FQVE1815     300G
NoDrive000000001 -       -                         -                    Not Installed
ArrayElement0002 da49    HP EG000300JWFVB          48B0A015FQVE1815     300G
NoDrive000000003 -       -                         -                    Not Installed

Temperatures: Controller Temperature Sensors  : 58 C, emc_1464_int:0:7:Vendor defined : 48 C, emc_1464_ext1:1:1:Chip ASIC     : 58 C, emc_1464_ext2:2:8:Vendor define : 48 C


This works in 12.3, but when I upgraded to 13.1, it would panic at boot.

panic: make_dev_alias_v: bad is_name (errror=22, si_name=enc0n5001438041aad8ba/type@0/slot@1/elmdesc@("Name": DriveBay1")/pass27

The installer ISOs also panic, so it’s nothing on the disks.



Who can address this?