Suggestions to improve the FreeBSD Handbook

From: Kolusion K <kolusion_at_post.com>
Date: Sun, 31 Dec 2023 10:58:07 UTC
Hi,


The FreeBSD Handbook needs improving and I have suggestions to improve it.

Yesterday I installed FreeBSD 14-RELEASE and it was a headache.

I wanted the GNOME desktop environment, so I navigated the FreeBSD Handbook table of contents to section 8.2.2. GNOME and followed the instructions. The outcome was that GNOME didn't work.

The problem was that GNOME depends on either the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD being installed and they weren't installed. There was no mentioned of them needing to be installed under section 8.2.2 GNOME.

Section 8.1 Synopsis states the user should understand how to install either the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD, but I didn't see that as I arrived at section 8.2.2 GNOME by navigating the table of contents.

I suggest stating at the start of section 8.2.2 GNOME that either the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD needs to be installed, and also do it under the sections of the other the desktop environments.

And section 8.1 Synopsis doesn't actually state the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD needs to be installed, it just states the user needs to understand how to install them. That isn't clear. It should state the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD needs to be installed in order to use a desktop environment.


I also suggest creating a section in the FreeBSD Handbook called 'Window systems' and bringing the the X Window System section and Wayland on FreeBSD section into it as subsections.

Then, for example, instead of it stating GNOME requires the X Window System or Wayland on FreeBSD being installed, it can just state that GNOME requires a window system be installed.


Sincerely,

Kolusion