Unhappy Xorg upgrade
alex-goncharov at comcast.net
Sat Jan 31 13:25:24 PST 2009
,--- You/vehemens (Sat, 31 Jan 2009 11:53:58 -0800) ----*
| In general when upgrading, you take your chances. If a port upgrade
| fails, you should fall back to what worked.
So, a *fundamental* (practically an OS component) port is brought in
-- and it disables my system. What is my way of action? Right --
install the old packages, taken from an FTP site (is there a way to
get the previous "source", that is all the ports/*/*/Makefile files?
Csup can only go forward -- or can it go back?)
When I install the old packages, I can no longer rebuild and install
new (say `csup'ed on 2009-03-01) port components, as one whole -- I
can only do it selectively, excluding from the upgrade most
X-dependent things. That sucks and will lead to a problem earlier or
| Trying to partial rebuild ports versus rebuilding from scratch after
| a major update is just asking for problems.
Exactly -- but I haven't done this -- and I have big problems with the
| There probably needs to be a more incremental approach when
| upgrading major ports. For example, I updated my system a piece at
| a time over the last several months, and had no significant problems
| with the offical x11 upgrade as the changes were small.
I've been rebuilding and reinstalling ports every weekend, for about
1.5 years -- with no problem until the last one, when the new X was
| And last, many of the video drivers have little if any support. If
| you have something other then ati/intel/nivdia, you should expect
| problems. Input drivers are in a similar state.
Both my systems I've been reporting problems with are using the `nv'
$ grep /modules/drivers /var/log/Xorg.0.log
(II) Loading /usr/local/lib/xorg/modules/drivers//nv_drv.so
One system (Dell Latitude) could not be made operational with the new
X at all; the other has garbage in the windows and the "captive mouse
pointer" -- both issues new in the new X.
-- Alex -- alex-goncharov at comcast.net --
More information about the freebsd-stable