clarification regarding netgraph and ipfw

Glenn Dawson glenn at antimatter.net
Fri Jul 30 00:00:56 PDT 2004


Greetings,

I have a firewall running -STABLE.  I'm using ipfw2 for filtering and 
ng_netgraph (via ng_tee) to export netflow data.

According to the man page for ng_ether, the lower hook gets raw ethernet 
frames as they come off the wire.  Reading the man page for ipfw it seems 
to say that if I turn on net.link.ether.ipfw in sysctl that it will also 
get things as they come off the wire.

So my question is, which one gets them first?

The reason I ask is that if I have an ipfw rule to block traffic from an 
IP, will it get counted by ng_netgraph?  Or will ipfw drop the packet 
before it even gets to ng_ether?

If the packets go through ng_ether first and then through ipfw, does anyone 
know if it's possible to reverse that behavior?  I'm doing billing based on 
traffic and don't want the netflow data to include packets that were 
dropped by ipfw.

Thanks in advance for any insight.

-Glenn



More information about the freebsd-stable mailing list