7.0-RELEASE && panic after ~4 hours

Sam Leffler sam at freebsd.org
Wed Mar 26 10:56:20 PDT 2008


Alphons "Fonz" van Werven wrote:
> Sam Leffler wrote:
>
>> I am aware only of issues with USB adapters being removed while 
>> wpa_supplicant is running.
>
> Actually, there's more I'm afraid.
>
> iwi: Don't know because I don't use that one. But it's a "cousin" of 
> wpi and
>      if I'm not mistaken it was the same person who initiated 
> development of
>      both drivers.
>
> wpi: No panics, but just doesn't work with wpa_supplicant at all 
> (fails to
>      associate). This is a known problem and people are working on it.

You said there were panics; please point me at PR's that show them or 
stop saying it.  Also these drivers are completely different and linking 
them is uninformed.

The problem with almost all the reports I've seen is they lack 
sufficient info to even respond.  Understand that most all Intel 
wireless cards up to the 4965 have issues with firmware mis-design that 
make developing reliable drivers hard (even more so given Intel's 
unwillingness in helping anyone not using linux).  For example the 
ipw+iwi drivers try to work around the fact there is no way to scan w/o 
also initiating an association.  But if you try and change the security 
parameters between scan+associate there are races that can cause the 
firmware to crash.  Most of the complaints I've seen are in this 
area--people running wpa_supplicant.

>
> Neither of these are USB adapters.
>
> rum: Works but panics after a while. PR has been filed, but seems to 
> be stuck
>      at feedback status (anyone know more about this one?).

PR #?  Unfortunately my rum card seems to have vanished.  The committer 
looking after rum has been occupied which may explain the inaction.

    Sam



More information about the freebsd-mobile mailing list