USB2.0 external hub and ehci question

Barry Bouwsma freebsd-misuser at remove-NOSPAM-to-reply.NOSPAM.dyndns.dk
Mon Sep 29 20:27:03 PDT 2003 

[Drop hostname part of IPv6-only address above to obtain IPv4-capable e-mail,
 or just drop me from the recipients and I'll catch up from the archives]


Hallo Hackers, I suppose I should post this to -current as the code in
question is derived from there, but I'm running it on RELENG_4, so...

I've ported the USB controller codes (uhci, ohci, and ehci) from -current
to 4.9-PRERELEASE in order to try and add USB2.0 support to 4.x, and I see
something that I also saw with the NetBSD ehci codes back last December;
namely, that I can't attach an external hub, supposedly with USB2.0
capability, and have it be recognized.

First, I seem to have no problems building just the uhci and ohci codes
into the usb.ko kernel module, and using them, though I haven't thoroughly
crash-tested them.

I've mixed all three controller codes, with the result that the hub is
not seen.  Nor is the external drive.  Which I attribute to my own
incompetence more than anything.  So to make things easier, I ditched
all but the ehci code and ignored the check for companion controllers,
to limit testing to just that.

With an external USB2.0 drive connected, I am able to see and mount it.
When I connect the external hub in its place, I get the error that the
port was disabled, STALLED -- just as I saw under old NetBSD.

I haven't built -current, or a more recent NetBSD, to see if their
behaviour is any different when faced with this hub.  Is it possible
I need some sort of quirks entry for this device, which I can use as
a USB1.x device fine?  Or do I not even get that far?


Here's the dmesg with uhubdebug and ehcidebug set to 1, with a few
comments...  (I may have added a few additional debug printf()s too)

ehci0: <NEC uPD 720100 USB 2.0 controller> mem 0xfdffdc00-0xfdffdcff irq 10 at device 8.2 on pci1
	using shared irq10.
ehci_init: start
usb0: EHCI version 0.95
ehci_init: sparams=0x2395
usb0: wrong number of companions (2 != 0)

    This here is the PCI card, along with my hack mentioned.
    [ snip ... ]

usb0: <NEC uPD 720100 USB 2.0 controller> on ehci0
usb0: USB revision 2.0
usbd_new_device bus=0xc1728000 port=0 depth=0 speed=0
ehci_open: pipe=0xc1727580, addr=0, endpt=0 (0)
usbd_new_device: adding unit addr=1, rev=200, class=9, subclass=0, protocol=1, maxpacket=64, len=18, speed=0
uhub0: NEC EHCI root hub, class 9/0, rev 2.00/1.00, addr 1
uhub0: 5 ports with 5 removable, self powered
ehci_open: pipe=0xc1727400, addr=1, endpt=129 (1)
usb_init_port: turn on port 1 power
usb_init_port: turn on port 2 power
usb_init_port: turn on port 3 power
usb_init_port: turn on port 4 power
usb_init_port: turn on port 5 power
ehci_pcd: change=0x02
uhub_explore: port 1 status 0x0501 0x0001
uhub_explore: status change hub=1 port=1
ehci after reset, status=0x00001005
ehci port 1 reset, status = 0x00001005
uhub speed is 3
usbd_new_device bus=0xc1728000 port=1 depth=1 speed=3
ehci_open: pipe=0xc1727180, addr=0, endpt=0 (1)
ehci_device_ctrl_close: pipe=0xc1727180
ehci_intr1: door bell
uhub_explore: usb_new_device failed, error=STALLED
uhub0: device problem, disabling port 1

I can provide a dmesg with a higher debug level, if it would be desired.


This is the same regardless of which of two USB2.0 PCI cards that I have
I am using.
The external hub that causes problems is seen with the USB1.x codes as

Sep 28 23:12:34 chubby /kernel: uhub2: Cypress Semiconductor product 0x6560, class 9/0, rev 2.00/0.07, addr 2
Sep 28 23:12:34 chubby /kernel: uhub2: 4 ports with 4 removable, self powered

And I can provide a patch I've used to usbdevs* to make this a bit more
descriptive...

Under NetBSD of last year, I could unplug and somewhat quickly re-plug
the external hub after the ehci port was disabled, and after a few tries,
I'd get it to be attached as a functioning USB1.x hub while ehci was
snoozing or something.  Of course, the ehci support was clearly marked
as beta then.


Oh heck, below I've attached an echidebug=3 dmesg, as it includes a few
<ACTIVE> and <HALTED> for anyone who can make sense out of it, with a
failed attempt at trying a random quirk.  I'll see about downloading some
USB utilities while I'm online to nab more useful info.


Thanks,
Barry Bouwsma

uhub_explore: port 1 status 0x0501 0x0001
uhub_explore: status change hub=1 port=1
ehci after reset, status=0x00001005
ehci port 1 reset, status = 0x00001005
uhub speed is 3
usbd_new_device bus=0xc1728000 port=1 depth=1 speed=3
ehci_open: pipe=0xc1727180, addr=0, endpt=0 (1)
ehci_alloc_sqtd: allocating chunk
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=8
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=8, actlen=8, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6ef80<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000011<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00f6ef40<> altnext=0x00f6ef40<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00f6ef80<> altnext=0x00f6ef80<>
  status=0x00008d00: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x04582398
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=2
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=2, actlen=0, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6efc0<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00f6ef40<> altnext=0x00f6ef50<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00f6efc0<> altnext=0x00f6efc0<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00f6ef40<> altnext=0x00f6ef40<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c80: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x80<ACTIVE>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=8
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=8, actlen=8, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6efc0<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000011<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00f6ef80<> altnext=0x00f6ef80<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00f6efc0<> altnext=0x00f6efc0<>
  status=0x00008d00: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x04582398
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=2
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=2, actlen=0, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6ef40<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00f6ef80<> altnext=0x00f6ef90<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00f6ef40<> altnext=0x00f6ef40<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00f6ef80<> altnext=0x00f6ef80<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c80: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x80<ACTIVE>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=8
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=8, actlen=8, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6ef40<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000011<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00f6efc0<> altnext=0x00f6efc0<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00f6ef40<> altnext=0x00f6ef40<>
  status=0x00008d00: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x04582398
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c40: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_alloc_sqtd_chain: start len=2
ehci_check_intr: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400
ehci_idone: xfer=0xc1729400, pipe=0xc1727180 ready
ehci_idone: len=2, actlen=0, status=0x40
ehci_idone: error, addr=0, endpt=0x00, status 0x40<HALTED>
QH(0xc174af80) at 0x00fedf80:
  link=0x00fedfc2<QH>
  endp=0x80082000
    addr=0x00 inact=0 endpt=0 eps=2 dtc=0 hrecl=0
    mpl=0x8 ctl=0 nrl=8
  endphub=0x40000000
    smask=0x00 cmask=0x00 huba=0x00 port=0 mult=1
  curqtd=0x00f6ef80<>
Overlay qTD:
  next=0x00f6efc0<> altnext=0x00f6efd0<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf40) at 0x00f6ef40:
  next=0x00f6ef80<> altnext=0x00f6ef80<>
  status=0x80000e00: toggle=1 bytes=0x0 ioc=0 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=2 stat=0x0
  buffer[0]=0x045823a8
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bf80) at 0x00f6ef80:
  next=0x00f6efc0<> altnext=0x00f6efc0<>
  status=0x80028d40: toggle=1 bytes=0x2 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=1 stat=0x40<HALTED>
  buffer[0]=0x04582390
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
QTD(0xc174bfc0) at 0x00f6efc0:
  next=0x00000001<T> altnext=0x00000001<T>
  status=0x00008c80: toggle=0 bytes=0x0 ioc=1 c_page=0x0
    cerr=3 pid=0 stat=0x80<ACTIVE>
  buffer[0]=0x00000000
  buffer[1]=0x00000000
  buffer[2]=0x00000000
  buffer[3]=0x00000000
  buffer[4]=0x00000000
ehci_idone: ex=0xc1729400 done
ehci_device_ctrl_close: pipe=0xc1727180
ehci_sync_hc: enter
ehci_sync_hc: cmd=0x00080061 sts=0x00008000
ehci_intr1: door bell
ehci_sync_hc: cmd=0x00080021 sts=0x00008000
ehci_sync_hc: exit
uhub_explore: usb_new_device failed, error=STALLED
uhub0: device problem, disabling port 1
uhub_explore: port 2 status 0x0500 0x0000
uhub_explore: port 3 status 0x0500 0x0000
uhub_explore: port 4 status 0x0500 0x0000
uhub_explore: port 5 status 0x0500 0x0000

More information about the freebsd-hackers mailing list