DHCP server in base
Doug Barton
dougb at FreeBSD.org
Wed Sep 15 18:27:27 UTC 2010
On 9/15/2010 7:25 AM, M. Warner Losh wrote:
> Yea. I agree too. Just because BIND was EOLd in 6 isn't a great
> argument against dhcp server.
That rather clearly was not the only element of my argument, and not
only is it disingenuous for you to indicate that it was, I don't
appreciate you doing so.
> Most of the code is there anyway, and it isn't evolving as fast as BIND.
That is actually a more rational argument, even if I don't agree with
it. FWIW, part of the reason that I don't agree with it is that at some
point, hopefully in the near future, we will want to include the DHCPv6
client in the mix somewhere; and when we do the code base is not going
to be as stable as we have enjoyed so far with the v4 dhclient.
> It would be very convenient to have this particular thing in the base,
> and we shouldn't be too dogmatic about never having any new 3rd party
> things in the base. After all, we just added more compression
> utilities to the base, and nobody said a peep.
I actually thought that change was rather silly, but it was clear that
there was so much critical mass in favor of it that there was no point
in stating a dissenting opinion. As part of the project's leadership you
should be careful not to mistake silence for agreement, or worse, support.
> This is analogous: we
> have good opportunity to integrate into the system, and users benefit
> from that integration.
Given your perspective of wanting more of a complete system in the base
I can certainly see how you would be supportive of this change. My
intent was to make the argument in a general way that this is the wrong
direction to go, and that users would benefit *more* from a robust
modularized system. The fact that the v4 DHCPd might accidentally be a
good candidate for including in the base today doesn't mean that doing
so is the right strategy for the long term.
Doug
--
... and that's just a little bit of history repeating.
-- Propellerheads
Improve the effectiveness of your Internet presence with
a domain name makeover! http://SupersetSolutions.com/
More information about the freebsd-current
mailing list